Understanding Geographical Indication Collective Marks (GICM) in Korea

A Geographical Indication Collective Mark (GICM) pertains to goods (such as agricultural, marine, and forest products, including their processed forms, industrial goods, and handicrafts) intrinsically linked to the geographical characteristics of a specific region. It is a type of collective mark that individuals engaged in the production, manufacturing, or processing of such goods within that region can collectively use to uphold their reputation (credit) and assure consumers of the product's quality. Introduced through the revision of the Korean Trademark Act (effective July 1, 2005), its primary objectives are to protect distinctive local brands, foster industrial development, and safeguard consumers from misunderstanding or confusion.

Defining the Geographical Indication Collective Mark (GICM)

A GICM is a trademark system that serves two main purposes: it indicates that a product originates from a specific geographical area, and it certifies that the product's quality, reputation, or other characteristics are closely linked to that particular region. Unlike standard trademarks, GICMs are typically applied for registration by associations or groups of producers within the designated region, allowing multiple producers who meet the criteria to use the mark collectively. This framework enables the systematic protection of the quality and value associated with regional specialties or renowned local products, thereby providing consumers with a reliable basis for trust.

Standard Trademark vs. Geographical Indication Collective Mark (GICM)

• Standard Trademark: Typically used exclusively by a specific individual or enterprise to distinguish their goods or services.
• Geographical Indication Collective Mark (GICM): Registered collectively by an association of producers within a specific geographical region and used by its members to protect the region's reputation and guarantee the quality linked to that origin.

Geographical Indication Collective Mark (GICM) vs. Geographical Indication Certification Mark (GICeM)

While both GICMs and Geographical Indication Certification Marks (GICeMs) share the commonality of being based on regional specificity, they differ significantly in terms of the eligible right holders and the manner of use:

• Eligible Right Holder:
  • GICM: Registration is available only to legal entities (e.g., cooperatives, agricultural associations) composed exclusively of individuals engaged in the production, manufacturing, or processing of the relevant goods within the designated geographical area.
  • GICeM: Registration is open to entities (which do not necessarily have to be legal entities) whose business involves 'certifying' aspects such as origin, production methods, or quality of goods produced by others. Crucially, the registrant of a GICeM cannot use the certification mark on their own products; use is permitted only by third parties whose goods meet the certified standards.
• User of the Mark:
  • GICM: Used collectively by the owner of the collective mark (the legal entity) and its constituent members who comply with the regulations.
  • GICeM: The owner of the certification mark does not use the mark directly on goods. Instead, third parties use the mark upon receiving 'certification' that their products meet the specific standards (e.g., origin, quality, production method) set by the certifying body.

Key Distinction: GICMs are primarily utilized by local producers and processors as a collective brand for their own goods. In contrast, GICeMs function as an indication of compliance granted to third-party goods, certifying that they meet certain pre-defined standards related to their geographical origin or characteristics.

Registration Requirements for a GICM

To qualify for registration, a Geographical Indication Collective Mark (GICM) must satisfy the following three core conditions:

1. Must Qualify as a Geographical Indication: The mark itself (e.g., brand name, logo) must contain or consist of a geographical name (such as the name of a region, locality, or place) and must serve to designate goods originating from that area, signifying their specific characteristics, reputation, or quality attributable to that origin.
2. Essential Link between Quality/Reputation/Characteristics and the Specific Region: The product itself must possess a particular quality, reputation, or other characteristics that are essentially attributable to the geographical environment (including natural factors like soil and climate, or human factors like traditional production methods) of the specific region.
3. Fulfillment of Collective Mark Registration Requirements:
   • The applicant must be a legal entity (corporation) composed solely of individuals engaged in the production, manufacturing, or processing of the goods eligible to use the geographical indication within that region.
   • The articles of association or internal regulations of the legal entity must be submitted, clearly defining matters such as the scope of membership, conditions for using the mark, quality standards for the goods, and measures for ensuring quality maintenance and control.

Examples: Representative examples of registered GICMs in Korea include "Icheon Ceramics," "Anseong Yugi (Brassware)," and "Hansan Mosi (Ramie Fabric)." These are widely known products whose defining characteristics are intrinsically linked to their respective geographical origins, making them eligible for protection under the GICM system.

Registration Procedure

The registration procedure for a GICM generally follows the standard trademark application process but includes a specific examination focused on the geographical indication requirements:

1. Application Filing: An application must be filed with the Korean Intellectual Property Office (KIPO), explicitly stating that it is for a GICM. It must be accompanied by supporting documents detailing the product's quality, reputation, and characteristics linked to the region, along with the applicant entity's articles of association or regulations.
2. Examination and Publication: A KIPO examiner reviews the application for compliance with all requirements, including those specific to GIs and collective marks. If the requirements are met, the application is published in the official gazette for public review.
3. Opposition Period: Following publication, there is a two-month period during which third parties may file an opposition against the registration.
4. Decision to Grant Registration & Certificate Issuance: If no opposition is filed, or if any filed opposition is ultimately dismissed, KIPO issues a decision to grant registration. Upon payment of the required registration fee, the GICM registration is finalized, and a Certificate of Registration is issued.

Effects of Registration and Rights Protection

• Accrual of Rights: Upon successful registration, the legal entity holding the GICM obtains the exclusive right to use the registered mark for the designated goods. This right is valid for 10 years and can be renewed indefinitely for subsequent 10-year periods. Members of the collective are also entitled to legitimately use the mark in accordance with the established regulations.
• Scope of Effect: The right holder can take action against the unauthorized use of identical or similar marks on identical or similar goods if such use is likely to cause confusion regarding the origin or quality. However, certain legal limitations may apply, such as rights held by bona fide prior users (those who were already using the mark in good faith before the GICM application was filed or rights arose).
• Restrictions on Transfer: Due to the inherent link to a specific region and the collective nature of the right, GICMs are generally non-transferable. Assignment may be permitted only in exceptional circumstances, such as a merger of the legal entity or a complete succession of the relevant business operations, and requires prior approval from KIPO.
• Invalidation and Cancellation:
  • Invalidation: An interested party or a KIPO examiner may file a trial for invalidation if the GICM registration violated substantive requirements at the time of registration (e.g., it didn't meet the GI criteria, or the applicant was ineligible).
  • Cancellation: Any person may file a trial for cancellation if, after registration, the right holder misuses the mark, or if changes (e.g., to the regulations) lead to public confusion regarding the origin or quality standards, or if the mark becomes generic for the goods it represents.
• Civil and Criminal Remedies: GICM right holders can pursue various legal remedies against infringement, including:
  • Civil: Injunctions (demands to cease infringement), claims for damages, and requests for measures to restore business reputation.
  • Criminal: Infringement of GICM rights can be subject to criminal penalties under the Trademark Act (e.g., for infringement or false indication of GI), providing a strong deterrent.

The Importance of Geographical Indication Collective Marks (GICM)

GICMs are vital tools for securing intellectual property rights for reputable regional specialties and industrial products. They serve as official proof of quality linked to origin, thereby enhancing the products' market value and reputation. This system allows producers within a region to benefit from the synergistic effects of a recognized collective brand. For consumers, GICMs provide a reliable means to identify authentic products, preventing confusion and ensuring they receive goods with the expected qualities associated with the geographical origin.

In light of the growing global popularity of K-Food and K-Culture, opportunities for Korean regional foods, handicrafts, and industrial products in international markets are expanding significantly. Securing GICM registration is therefore crucial for definitively protecting the origin, tradition, and reputation of these products, establishing a strong competitive advantage in the global marketplace.

Advice from Pine IP Firm

Pine IP Firm possesses extensive experience and deep expertise in all facets of brand protection strategy and enforcement, including specialized knowledge of Geographical Indication Collective Marks (GICMs), Geographical Indication Certification Marks (GICeMs), and standard trademarks.

Our dedicated services in this area include:

• Developing tailored application strategies for GICMs.
• Drafting and reviewing articles of association and internal regulations to meet KIPO requirements.
• Expertly managing the examination process, including responding to office actions and handling oppositions.
• Providing robust representation in administrative trials (invalidation, cancellation) and court litigation concerning infringement.

Whether you are considering applying for a GICM, require assistance with managing an existing registered mark, or need strategic guidance on addressing potential infringement issues, we encourage you to contact Pine IP Firm.

We are committed to providing customized, expert-driven solutions to effectively protect and promote the valuable regional specialties and traditional crafts of Korea, leveraging our top-tier professional capabilities.

‍